According to the New York Post, New York Yankees outfielder Brett Gardner was making an appearance at Duane Reade, a pharmacy, in New York City. An elderly woman came up to him and gave him a batch of homemade cookies in exchange for two autographed baseball for her grandkids.

“She said, ‘I am a huge fan, I made you some cookies so you can kick Philly’s butt,’ ” a witness recounted. “Gardner laughed, said thank you, then signed her balls.”